Compare property management companies
Fees and ratings for 54 managers in the Pensacola, FL area, Tallahassee, Key West / the Florida Keys and on the Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast. Click a company for its full profile and fee sources.
Showing 54 of 54 companies
| Leasing / placement fee | Fees online | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Action Keys Realty (Lower Keys)Key West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Alfonso Property Management (Gulfport/Pascagoula)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
2.9/5 (61 reviews) | Not published |
All Florida Keys Property ManagementKey West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.5/5 (68 reviews) | Not published |
Barrons Property ManagersPensacola, FL area |
9% (min $85/mo); premium plan $199/mo flat (+$10/mo for rents over $2,000-3,000) | 50% of one month's rent; leasing-only = 100% of one month ($1,000 min) |
3.9/5 (58 reviews) | Published |
Best of Key West Rentals (Truman & Co.)Key West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
BHHS Knight & Gardner Realty (Florida Keys)Key West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Brock PropertiesPensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote (Note: third-party Rentce list reports 10%; unverified) | Not published / call for quote (Note: Rentce reports 50%; unverified) |
4.6/5 (110 reviews) | Not published |
C West Realty (Gautier/Ocean Springs)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Clover Property Management (Pace)Pensacola, FL area |
8.5% / 10% / 12.5% (three plans) | 50% / 40% / 12.5% of first month's rent (by plan) |
5.0/5 (156 reviews) | Published |
Coastal Realty Services (Navarre/Crestview)Pensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.8/5 (244 reviews) | Not published |
CORE Property Management (Tallahassee)Tallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.7/5 (172 reviews) | Not published |
Davis & Decker Property Management (Navarre)Pensacola, FL area |
10% of gross rent (only when occupied; may vary by portfolio size) | Not published / call for quote |
4.4/5 (163 reviews) | Partial |
Destination Real Estate (Tallahassee)Tallahassee, FL area |
10% of monthly rent | $200 leasing fee |
4.0/5 (117 reviews) | Published |
ERA Old South PropertiesPensacola, FL area |
8%-12% of monthly rent | Placement-only: one month's rent (full-service leasing fee not stated) |
4.7/5 (1,461 reviews) | Published |
Fidelis Realty (Biloxi)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.9/5 (67 reviews) | Not published |
Gulf Coast Property Management Co.Pensacola, FL area |
10% of rent collected ($75/mo minimum) | 50% of first month's rent |
4.3/5 (21 reviews) | Published |
Gulf Coast Resort RentalsOcean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.5/5 (70 reviews) | Not published |
Historic Key West Annual RentalsKey West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
HomeFront Property Management (Ocean Springs)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.0/5 (23 reviews) | Not published |
HomeRiver Group (Pensacola)Pensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote (Note: promo: zero mgmt fees for 12 months with 2-year contract) | Not published / call for quote |
4.9/5 (188 reviews) | Not published |
Hometown Properties of the Gulf CoastPensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.5/5 (67 reviews) | Not published |
Investors Choice LLCTallahassee, FL area |
10% of monthly rental income (9% for 5-9 units; 8% for 10+ units) | 75% of one month's rent (minimum $400); placement-only: one month's rent or $500, whichever is greater |
No rating found | Published |
iTrip Key WestKey West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote (Note: site says "competitive management fees") | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Jackson Properties (Tallahassee)Tallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.6/5 (92 reviews) | Not published |
Kent Strauss Management & RealtyTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.3/5 (81 reviews) | Not published |
Key West Residential Property ManagementKey West / Florida Keys |
10% commission on any rental income (not charged on utility reimbursements) | Not published / call for quote |
4.3/5 (44 reviews) | Partial |
Lauer Real Estate GroupTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.0/5 (175 reviews) | Not published |
Main Street Property Management GroupPensacola, FL area |
10% of gross rent collected | 50% of one month's rent (vacant); $100 on-board fee if occupied |
4.7/5 (856 reviews) | Published |
Main Street Real Estate Group (Tallahassee)Tallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.9/5 (48 reviews) | Not published |
MS Coast Rentals (Biloxi)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
8%-12% of monthly rent + $185 setup fee | Placement-only: one month's rent |
4.9/5 (61 reviews) | Published |
Navy to Navy Homes PensacolaPensacola, FL area |
10% | One-time 75% of first month's rent |
4.7/5 (91 reviews) | Published |
Next Step Property Management (Biloxi)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
5.0/5 (4 reviews) | Not published |
NFI Property Management SolutionsPensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.5/5 (272 reviews) | Not published |
Opto Properties (Marathon / Key West)Key West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote (Note: pricing page says pricing is fully customizable) | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Picht & Sons Real EstateTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.9/5 (249 reviews) | Not published |
PMI Biloxi (Property Management Inc.)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
8% (Silver; page also shows "$59 plus 8%") / 10% (Gold) / 12% (Platinum) | 100% / 50% / $200 flat (by plan); placement-only 100% |
No rating found | Published |
PMI Gulf HorizonsPensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.0/5 (12 reviews) | Not published |
PRM IncOcean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
2.8/5 (172 reviews) | Not published |
Pro Players Realty USATallahassee, FL area |
8%-10% of gross monthly rent (10% if rent is $1,200 or less; 9% at $1,201-$1,500; 8% at $1,501+) | 50% of one month's rent with full management; placement-only 65% of one month's rent |
No rating found | Published |
Proper-T Management ServicesTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.2/5 (693 reviews) | Not published |
Property Management Division of Busch Realty GroupOcean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.7/5 (84 reviews) | Not published |
Rain Residential Properties (Ocean Springs)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote (Note: "rates vary by furnished/unfurnished and # of properties; only collect if rented") | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
Realty Masters of FloridaPensacola, FL area |
10% (8% active-duty military / investors with 3+ units) | 50% of first month's rent; placement-only = one full month |
4.0/5 (376 reviews) | Published |
Regional Property Services, Inc.Tallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.7/5 (147 reviews) | Not published |
Rent With IntegrityTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.2/5 (347 reviews) | Not published |
Southern Way RealtyOcean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
3.3/5 (121 reviews) | Not published |
Stay The KeysKey West / Florida Keys |
15% management fee (vacation rentals) | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Published |
Surfside Properties (Gulf Breeze)Pensacola, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.8/5 (107 reviews) | Not published |
Tallahassee Management & Leasing GroupTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.6/5 (44 reviews) | Not published |
The Lincoln Group (Pascagoula)Ocean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
No rating found | Not published |
TLH RealtyTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
2.5/5 (193 reviews) | Not published |
Vacant Solutions Property Management & RealtyTallahassee, FL area |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
5.0/5 (17 reviews) | Not published |
Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys (Marathon)Key West / Florida Keys |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
4.2/5 (153 reviews) | Not published |
Wendy Snyder - Rental Management, LLCOcean Springs / Mississippi Gulf Coast |
Not published / call for quote | Not published / call for quote |
2.8/5 (14 reviews) | Not published |
Sorting by management fee uses the first percentage each company publishes (the low end of a range or tier). Companies that don't publish a fee are listed last. Ratings come from third-party review aggregators (Birdeye, PropertyManagement.com); the exact source is on each profile. Data last checked October 2026. Always confirm current fees with the company. See the disclaimer.